Cruel Beauty

 Rosamund Hodge

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐
Genre: Fantasy + Retelling + Young Adult

Initial Impression
This is yet another book that showed up on the wheel of TBR. It has been sitting for a long time on my bookshelf. No idea why I have not picked it up despite loving the Beauty and the Beast story.

Summary
Cruel Beauty tries to reinvent Beauty and the Beast with a darker edge, mixing magic with political games in a world that feels a lot more dangerous than charming. The story centers on Nyx, a young woman who has been promised to Ignifex, the feared ruler of her realm.

Look, this isn't a love match—it’s pure strategy. Her family sees the marriage as a necessary evil, a sacrifice, and Nyx, having grown up carrying this weight of duty, is expected to kill her future husband. That whole plan, though, seems to get complicated pretty fast once real feelings start to get involved and muddy the water.

Nyx’s situation is just steeped in contradiction. She's been groomed as an assassin, yet at the same time, she’s just a girl trying to figure out where the line is between love, loyalty, and what everyone expects of her. The beginning leans heavily into explaining the politics of the realm. For some readers, that'll be totally immersive, but honestly, I found it a bit slow. It's not that the world-building is shallow—it just appears to occasionally drown out the emotional drama.

As her connection with Ignifex starts to deepen, the narrative naturally pivots inward. Nyx’s internal struggle becomes the absolute emotional core of the novel. There are other people who influence her journey, sure, but a few of them feel more like plot devices than actual, fully-realized people. I definitely found myself wishing for them to have a little more substance, especially considering how crucial they are to some of the major turns in the story.

The pace finally picks up near the end, shifting into high gear with some magical surprises and big confrontations. However, the ending itself may suggest the story ran out of space or steam right when things got interesting. I kept waiting for that special spark—the one that makes a classic retelling feel truly timeless—and while there were moments where it flickered, it never quite caught for me.

Characters
Nyx is complex, no doubt about it. She’s smart, she’s got courage, and she’s deeply conflicted. Hodge nails that complexity, though there were times when Nyx’s sheer indecision felt like she was stuck in a loop. It’s certainly realistic. Who wouldn’t be torn in her messed-up situation? But that repetition is likely to wear down the emotional impact a little bit.

Ignifex is a tougher nut to crack. He’s mysterious, he’s charismatic, and he's obviously more than just a typical fairytale villain. Still, some parts of his character remain frustratingly vague. I kept hoping for a better look inside his head, something that would make him feel less like a puzzle to be solved and more like an actual person I could understand.

The rest of the cast do what they’re supposed to, but they don't always manage to transcend that basic purpose. They add texture to the world, absolutely, but I wouldn't say they leave any sort of lasting impression. They come across as characters whose main job is to push the plot forward rather than genuinely challenge or enrich Nyx’s personal journey.

Writing Style
Hodge's writing is undeniably beautiful. There’s a wonderful lyrical quality to the prose that truly fits the whole dark fairy tale vibe. Because we get Nyx's thoughts straight from her first-person narration, there's a strong sense of intimacy, but that also means we spend a lot of time inside her head. Sometimes, maybe too much. There were moments that felt like they were just circling the same emotional point, which is what really dragged the pacing down for me.

Setting and Atmosphere
The world of Cruel Beauty is richly detailed—you’ve got your gothic palaces, shadowy forests, and weird magical rooms that all create a setting that’s both gorgeous and unsettling. It’s clear Hodge put a ton of effort into the details, and it pays off visually.

The tone leans heavily toward the dark side. There's a constant, low-level sense of unease, which makes sense given the themes of betrayal and moral compromise. Having said that, the tension doesn't always sustain itself. When the pacing starts to slip, the atmosphere loses some of its edge, and suddenly, the stakes don’t feel quite as urgent.

Final Thoughts
Cruel Beauty has a lot going for it: a great premise, a morally grey heroine, and a haunting world. Hodge’s prose is elegant, and the magical elements keep things interesting. However, the story doesn't quite manage to stick the landing. The occasional character flatness and those pacing issues prevent it from hitting the same emotional high notes as the classic tale it’s based on.

If you enjoy darker fantasy and you don’t mind a book that takes its time, this could absolutely be a winner for you. But if you’re looking for that huge, sweeping romance and emotional gut-punch of Beauty and the Beast, you might walk away feeling like it was missing something. For me, it was a perfectly decent read—it got me thinking in a few spots, but it wasn't the kind of book I'll remember forever.

Key Themes

• Love and Sacrifice
• Duty versus Desire
• Moral Ambiguity
• Power and Corruption
• Fate and Choice
• Isolation and Loneliness
• Redemption
• Family Obligation
• Inner Darkness
• Self-Acceptance